
Some of you may know I’m a moderately big Star Trek fan. Yes I’ve been to a convention. No I didn’t go in costume. Yes I’ve watched all episodes of the original series and Next Generation as well as all the movies. No I haven’t watched all the episodes of the decidedly crappier Deep Space Nine, Voyager, or Enterprise series.
I should also point for disclosure that I took a 48 credit course in college whose overarching theme was Star Trek. We used the show as a jumping off point to study sociology, screen writing, spacial physics, cognitive psychology, and many other related subjects.
Of particular interest to me was how the original series could run for only three seasons but make such a huge impact. After 1969 when the show ended, there wasn’t anything else (with the exception of a cartoon) until 1979 when the first movie came out. Yet in those 10 years the ethos of the characters and storylines grew and developed into one of the most popular mythologies of our time. How did this happen? Fans. The fans continued the adventures of the characters through unofficial “slash” stories and conventions.
So I was naturally excited that they’d come out with a new movie. All the other movies were pretty lame, starting with the abhorrent Star Trek I, which came out shortly after Star Wars and looked like a pitiful imitation, and ending with the attempt to bring the TNG cast onto the silver screen which never really panned out.
This latest movie though, they did a number of things right. Here’s my bullet-point grading of Star Trek 2009:
- Relative to other Trek movies: Great
- Relative to TV series: Really Good
- Compatibility with existing storylines and “science”: Great
- Acting overall: good enough
- Overall rating as a standalone movie: average-good (two stars on a four star scale, three stars on a five star scale)
I thought the writing was good to Star Trek standards, especially in the campy humor that only makes sense if you’re already familiar with the ethos. They did a good job making the storyline fun and accessible to everyone, dumbing down the complexity enough while still building on the epic timeline of, let’s face it, one of science fiction’s most revered characters: Spock.
I think they modeled this movie mostly after the original series, minus the presence of a Gene Roddenberry-esque omnipotent creature. Roddenberry always tried to introduce the concept of something larger than us, in more control than us.
For our main characters, they did a great job setting them up. The legendary James Tiberius Kirk especially. None of the prior movies or TV series really gave us the back story we needed to understand why Kirk got to captain the best ship in the fleet. Knowing that he’s a Will Hunting like smarty pants really helps to understand his position in Starfleet.
Overall, I give it a big hearty thumbs up, from an insiders perspective. For people who don’t know the entire Star Trek context, it’s a good science fiction movie with plenty of fun action, although much of the humor predicates on knowing some back story of the characters (Scotty in particular made me LOL).

Social Links